This is not the first case that has been brought against the caffeinated alcohol sector. In 2008, the FDA investigated the caffeinated offerings of major beverage companies Anheuser-Busch Inc. and MillerCoors Brewing (Food Consumer). They ordered them to stop producing their products, which for Anheuser-Busch included Tilt and Bud Extra, and for MillerCoors included Sparks (FDA). However, to fill the gap in the market left by their absense, smaller companies created new products and gained market share. Their provocative names, such as Evil Eye, Max Fury, and Slingshot Party Gel, target the youth demographic and perpetuate the drinks' popularity (Wall Street Journal). Michele Simon, a research and policy director at Marin Institute, an alcohol watchdog group, says that alcoholic energy products became popular after the combination of Red Bull and vodka in the late 1990s (Los Angeles Times). Dr. Joshua Sharfstein, the principal deputy commissioner of food and drugs of the FDA, spoke about the problems with mixing alcohol and caffeine. He said that the FDA found as many as 26% of college students use drinks with both ingredients. The caffeine masks the effects of the alcohol, making people believe they are less intoxicated than they actually are. These people are more susceptible to being aggressors or victims of sexual assault, drunk driving, or riding in cars with drunk drivers. Although caffeine has been approved by the FDA for use in soft drinks, it was never approved to be mixed with alcohol. Under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, anything added to food or drink needs to be pre-approved by the agency to be officially "Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS)". This requires the company file a petition to the FDA. Dr. Sharfstein says that the FDA has not reached a conclusion about the drinks but definitely has serious concerns (Food Consumer).
A paper written by Amelia M. Arria, Ph.D. and colleagues from the University of Maryland College Park found that the use of caffeine in alcoholic beverages can cause a series of health problems. The caffeine causes increases in consumption, which leads to higher levels of intoxication. Arria et. al also suggests an increase of risk of heart arrhythmias that may be accentuated by the combined intake of energy drinks and alcohol. The paper's overall conclusion states, "The consumption of caffeinated alcoholic beverages has been associated with increased risk of serious injury to oneself and to others, as the result of driving while intoxicated, sexual assault, and other dangerous behaviors" (Food Consumer).
Some of the companies targeted by the investigation feel that the attack is unwarranted. One company, Delicious Brands, makes a product called Lotus Vodka that contains caffeine, vitamins, and other ingredients. They claim that their product is marketed towards people in their 30s at fine dining restaurants. Although the company said it will comply with FDA requests, it says, "Brands like ours are being hit in the crossfire" (Los Angeles Times). Caffeine is a psychoactive stimulant drug that alters brain function, leading to changes in perception, mood, consciousness, and behavior (Food Consumer). Makers of these beverages should reconsider their detrimental effects and pull them from the market immediately. Adding together the effects of alcohol and the effects of caffeine is a recipe for disaster.
No comments:
Post a Comment