Sunday, October 25, 2009

Smart Choices? Unlikely

A nutritional labeling program that declared Froot Loops and Cracker Jacks as "smart choices" said it will voluntarily postpone operations in a statement released on Friday, October 23rd. The Smart Choices Program was created in August by a group of food industry leaders in order to aid consumers with their food purchasing choices. Companies include Kellogg Co, Kraft Foods Inc., General Mills Inc., Unilever PLC, PepsiCo Inc., Quaker Foods, and ConAgra Foods (Reuters). According to the program's website, SmartChoicesProgram.com, qualifying for the program requires that "a product must meet a comprehensive set of nutrition criteria based on the Dietary Guidelines for Americans and other sources of nutrition science and authoritative dietary guidance." Smart Choices engages in a form of labeling called front-of-package labeling which places its seal of approval on the front of foods, making the information easily accessible to a busy consumer.


This reevaluation of the program is a direct response to a statement released by the Food and Drug Administration earlier in the week that stressed the need to reevaluate all labeling programs. According to the Los Angeles Times, the FDA said, "There were so many labeling programs with different criteria that they may mislead consumers about the health benefits of certain foods." Foods given the Smart Choices label include Kraft Macaroni and Cheese Baked Cheese Crackers, Country Crock spread, and Cocoa Krispies (Reuters). Michael Jacobson, director of the Center for Science and Public Interest, gives an example that is particularly shocking. "Consider Kraft's Strawberry Bagel-ful, which is a mostly white-flour bagel stuffed with cream cheese and strawberry purée that is sweetened with sugar and colored with red dye 40. It's exactly the kind of food we should be eating less of, but it gets the Smart Choices logo" (foodconsumer.org).

Officials with Smart Choices say that they informed the FDA about their nutrition criteria during every stage of development. Jacobson was one of the FDA members working with the program, but resigned last year out of concerns that the criteria for nutritious foods was too loose. The issue was recently inflamed by a letter sent to the FDA by Rosa L. Delauro, chairwoman of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Agricultural Rural Development. Her letter from September 22nd expressed her concern about Smart Choices' front-of-pack labeling as being deceptive. The FDA responded by doing some research about labeling practices. They found that consumers are less likely to look at the nutrition facts of a product that has front-of-package labeling. The authority to regulate FOP labeling lies in the hands of the FDA, not the producer. A letter with all of this information was sent to Sarah Krol, general manager of the Smart Choices Program, which is what lead to the October 23rd halt to the program (foodconsumer.org).

Although some highly processed products may meet the very loose nutritional criteria designated by the Smart Choices Program, labeling Froot Loops and Cracker Jacks as smart choices is deceptive to consumers. Common sense about what is healthy and what is not needs to play a role in the redesigned guidelines for the Smart Choices Program.

No comments:

Post a Comment