In today's harsh economic climate, Americans are looking to cut back on unnecessary expenditures. For some, the high prices paid for food make up a huge portion of their used income. Healthy household staples like fruits, vegetables, and lean meats get put on the (metaphorical) cutting board. Pricey restaurants that use quality ingredients become way out of reach. So what are Americans eating?
According to an article in the Houston Chronicle, recessionistas are cutting food costs by taking advantage of the value menus at fast food restaurants (Latson, 2009). Direct evidence of this trend can be seen in recent financial reports at McDonalds, where profits increased in the first two quarters of this year. Whole Foods, an organic supermarket chain, saw a clear decline in profits.
Money saving is not the only reason consumers are turning towards high-sugar, high-fat foods. An article on CNN.com titled "Why We Eat Too Much, And How to Get Control" (Grumann, 2009) explained how stress levels can affect the hormones cortisol and insulin, which in turn affect meal choices. "Cortisol and insulin shift our preferences toward comfort foods--high-fat, high-sugar, or high-salt foods," says Elissa Epel, Ph.D., an associate professor at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), Department of Psychiatry and a leader of the UCSF Center on Obesity Assessment, Study, and Treatment."
How can we prevent the economic crisis from further exacerbating the obesity crisis? Recent studies and articles by leading nutrition experts have suggested putting a tax on sugary soft drinks to prevent consumption and discourage thrifty customers from purchasing them. However, taxing harmful foods is not a new idea. A "fat tax" has been proposed by researchers since the 1980s, most notably by Kelly D. Brownell, PhD, director of the Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity at Yale (Wikipedia, Fat Tax). Sugary drinks have come under fire for being a leading contributor to the obesity epidemic. An article in the Boston Globe reported that "'Sugar-sweetened beverages,’’ Dr. Thomas Frieden, director of the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, wrote in April in The New England Journal of Medicine, “may be the single-largest driver of the obesity epidemic.'"(Smith, 2009). In 2000, soft drinks were the largest calorie contributor in Americans' diet, accounting for 7 percent of daily consumption.
A commentary of the article cited above in The New England Journal of Medicine was posted online this past week on September 16th. Authors suggest a national tax of 1 cent per ounce of sugar-sweetened beverages, and believe this would raise $14.9 billion in its first year. This money would then be used to finance health programs, making this legislation very similar to that of smoking taxation. (Cooney, 2009).
A sugar-laden soda tax sounds great in theory, but what are the problems? The main issue is that a sugar tax is a regressive tax. This means that the tax would have a greater affect on the poor, making it impossible for them to buy sugary drinks. Without subsidies on healthy drinks, the poor won't be able to afford anything, which does not solve any problems. Additionally, many people feel like their civil liberties are being infringed upon when the government taxes something that they have a right to purchase. One commenter on the Boston Globe's health blog "White Coat Notes" expressed this sentiment by saying, "I don't know if anyone realizes this, but taxes are NOT supposed to be a form of punishment." (Cooney, 2009).
Although Americans are turning towards unhealthy foods and drinks for financial savings and mental support, a tax on unhealthy beverages could deter a large part of these behaviors. However, without additional support from the government to subsidize healthier foods, this tax would only create more nutritional and social issues. Further investigation is needed to examine possible unwanted effects and necessary subsidies to make a soda tax successful.
Sunday, September 20, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment